Law library
Judicial reviews of decisions
Last updated: October 23, 2024
A party may seek judicial review of Tribunal decisions. See:
Tribunal decisions are listed below, if there is court decision on a judicial review application. Links to the court decisions are given, where available.
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
A
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| A v. B 2011 BCHRT 74 | Petition struck – 2012 BCSC 892 Appeal dismissed – 2013 BCCA 403 Application for leave to appeal dismissed May 8, 2014 – S.C.C., File No. 35736 |
| A v. Society and others (No. 2) 2015 BCHRT 143 2015 BCHRT 163 | Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1883 Appeal dismissed – 2018 BCCA 84 Application for leave to appeal dismissed February 28, 2019 – S.C.C. File No. 38383 |
| A v. The Society, 2017 BCHRT 234 | Petition allowed in part – 2019 BCSC 666 |
| A.M. v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of British Columbia as represented by the Ministry of Children and Family Development 2015 BCHRT 34 | Petition allowed – 2017 BCSC 89 |
| A. v. Keebler (No. 2) 2016 BCHRT 63 | Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 1194 |
| Abrams v. North Shore Free Press Ltd. (c.o.b. “North Shore News”) (February 2, 1999) | Petition adjourned in part; petitioner’s constitutional challenge remitted to Tribunal – BCSC Victoria, Registry No. 99/1644 Appeal dismissed – 2001 BCCA 22 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C., File No. 28452 |
| Abrams v. Collins (No. 5) 2001 BCHRT 43 | Petition dismissed – 2002 BCSC 1774 Appeal dismissed – 2004 BCCA 96 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C., File No. 30259 |
| Adolphs v. Boucher Institute of Naturopathic Medicine 2013 BCHRT 78 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 298 |
| Ahlwat v. City of Surrey 2001 BCHRT 21 | Petition dismissed – 2002 B.C.S.C 63 |
| Andrews v. Steelworkers of America et al (November 29, 2006 letter decision) | Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 1079 |
| Armstrong v. B.C. (Ministry of Health) (No. 5) 2008 BCHRT 19 | Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 856 Appeal allowed – 2010 BCCA 56 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. Registry No. 33643 |
| Asad v. Kinexus Bioinformatics 2008 BCHRT 293 | Petitions dismissed – 2010 BCSC 33 |
| Azagrar v. Nicholas Shaw and Shaw (No. 6), 2007 BCHRT 158 | Petition dismissed for want of prosecution: January 30, 2009 |
B
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Baharloo v. UBC and another (No. 2) 2011 BCHRT 290 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 762 Appeal dismissed –2016 BCCA 277 |
| Bali and Bali v. Imperial Parking Canada Corporation 2003 BCHRT 92 | Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 643 |
| Ballendine v. Willoughby and others (No. 4) 2007 BCHRT 162 | Petition allowed – 2007 BCSC 2009 |
| Bartuk v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority 2016 BCSC 74 | Petition dismissed – 2016 BCSC 74 |
| Bates v. Overwaitea Food Group 2006 BCHRT 44 | Petition allowed – 2006 BCSC 1201 |
| Becker v. Cariboo Chevrolet Oldsmobile Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (No. 2) 2004 BCHRT 80 | Petition allowed in part – 2006 BCSC 43 |
| Becker v. Cariboo Chevrolet Oldsmobile Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (No. 3) 2004 BCHRT 139 | |
| Bellefleur v. The District of Campbell River (No.2) 2002 BCHRT 28 | Petition allowed – 2003 BCSC 1109 Decision on costs – May 22, 2003 (oral reasons for judgment) Appeal allowed – 2004 BCCA 601 |
| Bennett v. Classy Car Care Inc. (December 23, 1998) | Petition dismissed – BCSC Nanaimo, Registry No. S23342 |
| Berezoutskaia v. IWA, Sodexho and others 2005 BCHRT 133 | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1170 Appeal dismissed – 2006 BCCA 95 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31426 |
| Bihari v. Deltec Electric Ltd. 2019 BCHRT 114 | Petition dismissed – 2020 BCSC 1450 |
| Bolster v. BC (Min. of Public Safety and Solicitor General) 2004 BCHRT 32 | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1491 Appeal dismissed – 2007 BCCA 65 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31963 |
| Bradley v. Fire-Trol Canada Company 2005 BCHRT 212 | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1646 |
| Brady v. Interior Health Authority 2005 BCHRT 200 | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1403 |
| Brar and others v. British Columbia Veterinary Medical Association and Osborne (No. 17) 2010 BCHRT 260 | Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 486 |
| Breuker v. Arrowsmith Lodge Health Care Society and another 2019 BCHRT 55 | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 2337 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Bro and Scott v. Moody (No. 2), 2010 BCHRT 8 | Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 657 |
| Brown v. PML and Wightman (No.3) 2008 BCHRT 118 | Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1429 |
| Brown v. PML and Wightman 2007 BCHRT 377 | Petition dismissed – November 26, 2008 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Buntain and others v. Marine Drive Golf Club and others 2005 BCHRT 119 | Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 1434 Appeal dismissed – 2007 BCCA 17 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31426 |
| Byelkova v. Fraser Health Authority and another 2019 BCHRT 118 | Petition allowed – 2021 BCSC 1312 Appeal dismissed – 2022 BCCA 205 |
C
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Callaghan v. University of Victoria 2005 BCHRT 589 | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1503 |
| Carter v. Travelex Canada and Travelex UK (No. 3) 2007 BCHRT 275 | Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 405 Appeal dismissed – 2009 BCCA 180 |
| Cassidy v. Emergency Health and Services Commission and others (No. 2) 2008 BCHRT 125 | Petition allowed – 2011 BCSC 1003 |
| Caster v. Walter Evans (No. 2), 2012 BCHRT 163 | Petition dismissed – February 6, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment) Appeal dismissed – 2013 BCCA 529 |
| CFO v. The Organization (No. 4) 2022 BCHRT 55 | Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 1758 |
| Chaloob v. Vancouver Police Department, 2005 BCHRT 311 | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1836 |
| Chan v. UBC and others (No. 2) 2012 BCHRT 12 | Petition allowed – 2013 BCSC 942 |
| Chaudhary v. Smoother Movers (No. 2) 2009 BCHRT 176 | Petition allowed – June 29, 2012 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Chen and others v. City of Surrey and others, 2012 BCHRT 284 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 539 Appeal dismissed – 2015 BCCA 57 |
| Chiang v. Vancouver Board of Education and another, 2014 BCHRT 37 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 1859 |
| Chilliwack Teachers’ Associations v. Neufeld 2021 BCHRT 6 | Petitions dismissed – 2023 BCSC 1460 |
| Chubb-Kennedy v. Edgewater Casino and another, 2013 BCHRT 213 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 416 Appeal dismissed – 2015 BCCA 9 |
| Cima v. Intact Distributors and another, 2015 BCHRT 140 | Petition dismissed – May 9, 2016, oral reasons for judgment |
| Complainant v. College of Physicians and Surgeons of BC (No. 2), 2018 BCHRT 189 | Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 1898 |
| Conklin v. University of British Columbia, 2018 BCHRT 130. Conklin v. University of British Columbia, 2018 BCHRT 262 | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1569 Appeal dismissed – 2022 BCCA 333 |
| Corren v. Abbotsford School Board, 2010 BCHRT 32 | Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 529 |
| Cowie v. Grand Forks District Savings Credit Union (No. 2) 2006 BCHRT 167 | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 2008 |
| Crane v. B.C. (Ministry of Health Services and others) 2005 BCHRT 361 | Petition allowed – 2007 BCSC 460 |
| Crockford v. Her Majesty the Queen in the Right of the Province of British Columbia 2004 BCHRT 78 | Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 663 Appeal allowed – 2006 BCCA 360 |
| Crozier v. Richmond (City) (June 30, 1998) | Petitions dismissed – B.C.S.C.Vancouver, Registry Nos. A982351, A990410 Appeal allowed – 2001 BCCA 77 |
D
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Dadvand and Ross v. CB Richard Ellis Ltd. and others 2004 BCHRT 36 | Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 1969 |
| Daughter M by Mother K v. Board of Education of a Vancouver Island School District 2019 BCHRT 274 | Petition allowed – oral ruling, October 15, 2020, (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Dean v. University of Victoria and another, 2012 BCHRT 71 | Petition dismissed – August 30, 2013, (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Dela Merced v. Aluminum Curtain Wall System Inc. (Letter Decision dated March 22, 2011) 2011 BCHRT 342 | Petition dismissed – July 17, 2012, (oral reasons for judgment) |
| De Silva v. Fraser Health Authority and BCNU (No. 2) 2011 BCHRT 195 | Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 1710 |
| Dixon v. Victoria Shipyards and others 2011 BCHRT 46 | Employer petitions allowed , union petitions allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 161 |
| Duncan v. Trustees: Retail Wholesale Union Pension Plan 2016 BCHRT 22 | Petition allowed – 2017 BCSC 2375 |
| Dunkley v. UBC and another 2015 BCHRT 100 | Petition dismissed – July 26, 2016, 2016 BCSC 1383 |
E
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Edwards v. Foglia and Champion Cabs 2006 BCHRT 517 | Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 861 |
| Engler v. Coast Mountain Bus Company and another 2009 BCHRT 206 | Petition dismissed – March 11, 2010 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Eva obo others v. Spruce Hill Resort and another, 2018 BCHRT 238 | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 2504 |
| Evans v. UBC 2007 BCHRT 348 | Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1026 |
F
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Feldman v. Westfair Foods Ltd. (c.o.b. Real Canadian Superstore) June 11, 1997 1997 BCHRT 18 | Petition dismissed April 2, 1998 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Figliola and others v. Workers’ Compensation Board (No. 2) 2008 BCHRT 374 | Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 377 Appeal allowed – 2010 BCCA 77 Appeal allowed – 2011 SCC 52 |
| Ford v. Lavender Co-operative (No. 3) 2009 BCHRT 38 | Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 1437 Appeal dismissed – 2011 BCCA 114 |
| Forsyth v. Coast Mountain Bus Company and another (No. 2) 2011 BCHRT 133 | Petition dismissed – February 2, 2012 (oral reasons for judgement) Appeal dismissed – 2013 BCCA 257 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 35501 |
| Francescutti v. City of Vancouver and another, 2014 BCHRT 236 | Petition allowed – 2016 BCSC 1191 Appeal allowed – 2017 BCCA 242 |
| Francis v. Victoria Shipyards (No. 3), 2012 BCHRT 233 | Petition allowed – 2013 BCSC 1410 |
G
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Garand v. K.E. Gostlin Enterprises Ltd. doing business as Canadian Tire Corp. 2002 BCHRT 8 | Petition allowed – November 13, 2002 (Oral Reasons for Judgment) |
| Gardezi v. Black Press Group and another, 2011 BCHRT 123 | Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 196 |
| Gardezi v. The Postive Living Society of BC and another, 2017 BCHRT 63 | Petition allowed in part – 2019 BCSC 666 |
| Gareau v. Lawrence 2001 BCHRT 11 | Petition dismissed – November 13, 2002 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Gatica and Migrante obo Temporary Foreign Workers from Guatemala v. Golden Eagle Blueberry Farm 2020 BCHRT 214 | Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 304 |
| Ghinis v. Crown Packaging Ltd. | Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 1809 Appeal allowed – 2002 BCCA 172 |
| Gichuru v. Pallai 2012 BCHRT 327 | Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1083 Appeal dismissed – 2018 BCCA 78 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 38123 |
| Gichuru v. Pallai (No. 2) 2010 BCHRT 125 | Constitutional challenge to s. 27(1)(c) dismissed – 2018 BCSC 2220 |
| Gichuru v. Purewal and another 2017 BCHRT 19 | Petition allowed – 2019 BCSC 484 Costs – 2019 BCSC 951 |
| Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No. 11) 2012 BCHRT 275 | Petition allowed in part – 2013 BCSC 1325 Application to re-open – 2013 BCSC 2088 Appeal dismissed – 2014 BCCA 396 |
| Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No. 9) 2011 BCHRT 185 | Petition allowed in part – 2013 BCSC 1325 Appeal dismissed – 2014 BCCA 396 |
| Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No.3), 2006 BCHRT 402 | Petition allowed – 2007 BCSC 1767 |
| Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia (No. 2) 2008 BCHRT 344 | Petition dismissed – October 2, 2009 (oral reasons for judgement) Appeal dismissed – 2010 BCCA 543 |
| Gichuru v. The Law Society of British Columbia, [Pre-Hearing Memorandum dated October 7, 2008] | Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 522 |
| Gichuru v. Vancouver Swing Society (February 1, 2017 letter decision) | Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 402 Appeal dismissed – 2021 BCCA 103 Leave to appeal denied – SCC File No. 39736 Reconsideration application dismissed – 2021 BCCA 246 |
| Gichuru v. WCAT 2007 BCHRT 189 | Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 904 Appeal dismissed – 2010 BCCA 191 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – SCC File No. 33741 |
| Gill et al. v. British Columbia (Ministry of Health ) 2001 BCHRT 34 | Petition allowed in part – 2003 BCSC 1112 |
| Gonzalez v. B.C. (Min. of Attorney General et al) (May 13, 2008 letter decision) | Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 639 |
| Gordy v. Painter’s Lodge 2000 BCHRT 16 | Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 1728 BC Human Rights Commission application to intervene dismissed – 2001 BCCA 389 Appeal allowed – 2002 BCCA 495 |
| Graham v. NLK Consultants Inc. | Petition allowed – B.C.S.C.Vancouver Registry No. A981548 |
| Grant v. City of Vancouver and others (No. 2), 2006 BCHRT 261 | Petition allowed – 2006 BCSC 1855 |
| Gray and others v. University of British Columbia Students’ Union – Okanagan (No. 2) 2008 BCHRT 16 | Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1530 |
| Gregoire v. BC (Ministry of Public Safety) 2004 BCHRT 25 | Petition allowed – 2005 BCSC 154 Appeal dismissed – 2005 BCCA 585 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31288 |
| Gregory v. University of British Columbia letter decision | Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 119 |
| Guthrie v. Levitt | Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C., Vancouver Registry No. A981656 |
H
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Hackett v. Telecommunications Workers Union and Doubt, 2011 BCHRT 18 | Petition allowed – February 3, 2012 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Hale v. University of British Columbia Okanagan (No. 2) 2019 BCHRT 23 | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 729 |
| Hamedanian v. Capilano University and others, 2009 BCHRT 308 | Petition dismissed – February 9, 2011 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Hanlon v. City of North Vancouver and another 2016 BCHRT 123 | Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1607 |
| Harvey v. Gibraltar Mines Ltd. (No. 2) 2020 BCHRT 193 | Petition allowed – 2022 BCSC 385 Appeal allowed – 2023 BCCA 168 |
| Harun-ar-Rashid v. Ministry of Education (Teacher Regulation Branch) 2021 BCHRT 75 | Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 965 BCCA Appeal dismissed 2023 BCCA 276 Leave to appeal denied 2024 CanLII 10152 (SCC) |
| Hayes v. Vancouver Police Department and Barker 2005 BCHRT 590 | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1217 Appeal dismissed – 2008 BCCA 148 |
| Heilman v. Unger & The Upper Room Mission 2004 BCHRT 66 Correction | Petition dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1812 |
| Hill v. WCAT 2008 BCHRT 253 | Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 107 Appeal allowed in part – 2011 BCCA 49 |
| Hines v. Canpar Industries (No. 2) 2005 BCHRT 430 | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 800 |
| Hughson v. Kelowna (City) | Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C.Kelowna, Registry No. 43745 |
| Hunter v. British Columbia (Ministry of Health) (December 21, 1999) 1999 BCHRT 65 | Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 1798 |
| Hutchinson v. B.C. (Min. of Health) 2004 BCHRT 58 | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1421 Application for stay dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1536 |
J
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| J.J. v. School District No. 43 (Coquitlam) and another 2007 BCHRT 448 2008 BCHRT 223 2008 BCHRT 360 | Petition allowed – 2012 BCSC 523 Appeal allowed – 2013 BCCA 67 |
| James obo James v. Silver Park Campsites and another (No. 2), 2011 BCHRT 370 | Petition allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 1437 Appeal allowed – 2013 BCCA 292 |
| James obo James v. Silver Park Campsites and another (No. 3), 2012 BCHRT 141 | Petition allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 1437 Appeal allowed – 2013 BCCA 292 |
| Jiwany and Jiwany v. West Vancouver Municipal Transit 2005 BCHRT 172 | Petition dismissed – August 10, 2006 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Johnston v. St. James Community Service Society and others 2004 BCHRT 51 | Petition allowed – 2004 BCSC 1807 |
| Johnston v. St. James Community Service Society and others (No. 2) 2004 BCHRT 59 | Petition allowed – 2004 BCSC 1807 |
| Joinson v. Teck Coal and another 2013 BCHRT 215 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 642 |
| Joinson v. Teck Coal and another (No.2) 2013 BCHRT 300 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 642 |
| Jubran v. The Board of School Trustees of School District No. 44 (North Vancouver) 2002 BCHRT 10 | Petition allowed – 2003 BCSC 6 Decision on costs – May 22, 2003 (oral reasons for judgement) Appeal allowed – 2005 BCCA 201 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C., File No. 30964 |
K
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Kamali v. Affordable Housing and others 2009 BCHRT 216 | Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 692 |
| Karbalaeiali v. Vancouver Trolley and another 2009 BCHRT 227 | Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 1130 Application to late file appeal materials dismissed – January 19, 2011 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Kelly v. Residential Ready Mix 2002 BCHRT 40 | Petition allowed – November 10, 2003 (Oral Reasons for Judgment) |
| Kelly v. UBC (No. 3) 2012 BCHRT 32. Kelly v. UBC (No. 4) 2013 BCHRT 302 | Petition allowed in part – 2015 BCSC 1731 Appeal dismissed – 2016 BCCA 271 |
| Kenworthy v. Brewers’ Distributor and another 2014 BCHRT 237 | Petition dismissed – 2015 BCSC 1670 |
| Kerr v. Boehringer Ingelheim (Canada) (No. 4) 2009 BCHRT 196 | Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 427 Appeal dismissed 2011 BCCA 266 |
| Kilshaw and Hallam v. Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (May 25, 1999) 1999 BCHRT 29 | Petition allowed – 2000 BCSC 580 Appeal allowed – 2001 BCCA 193 |
| Kirk v. City of Burnaby and another 2012 BCHRT 204 | Petition allowed – 2014 BCSC 155 |
| Koehler v. Carson and Others (No. 2) 2006 BCHRT 178 | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1779 |
| Kono v. Strata Plan LMS 2685 and another 2017 BCHRT 143 | Petition dismissed – June 26, 2018, 2018 BCSC 1045 |
L
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| L.M.A. v. British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal (Letter Decision dated July 6, 2006) | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 1889 |
| Legere v. Provincial Health Services Authority and others, 2012 BCHRT 154 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 306 |
| Lewis v. B.C. (Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General) 2011 BCHRT 352 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 1980 |
| Long v. City of Vancouver 2009 BCHRT 431 | Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 643 |
| Lord v. Fraser Health Authority and another 2020 BCHRT 64 | Petition allowed – 2021 BCSC 2176 |
| Lorenz v. Mainstream Association for Proactive Community Living 2010 BCHRT 305 | Petition dismissed – February 23, 2011 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| Lungu v. B.C. (Min. of Children and Family Development) (No. 2), 2011 BCHRT 341 | Petition dismissed – February 20, 2014 (oral reasons for judgement) Appeal dismissed – 2016 BCCA 136 |
M
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| MacGarvie v. Friedmann (No. 4), 2009 BCHRT 47 | Petition allowed – 2011 BCSC 1147 Appeal allowed – 2012 BCCA 445 |
| MacTavish v. Tennant (c.o.b. “Look Model Talent”) (November 26, 1998) 1998 BCHRT 67 | Petition dismissed – September 29, 1999 (oral reasons for judgement) Petition allowed – April 5, 2000 (oral reasons for judgement) |
| McCormick v. Fasken Martineau Dumoulin (No. 2) 2010 BCHRT 347 | Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 713 Appeal allowed – July 19, 2012 Appeal dismissed – 2014 SCC 39 |
| McCreath v. Victoria Taxi 2015 BCHRT 153 | Petition dismissed – September 13, 2016 (oral reasons for judgement) Appeal dismissed – 2017 BCCA 342 Application for leave to appeal – dismissed July 12, 2018, S.C.C. File No. 37947 |
| McCulloch v. Fraser Health Authority, City of Surrey (January 21, 2016 letter decision) | Petition dismissed – 2019 BCSC 624 |
| McCulloch v. Nociar (May 17, 2016 letter decision) | Petition allowed – 2019 BCSC 624 |
| McDonald v. Schuster Real Estate 2005 BCHRT 177 | Petition dismissed for want of prosecution: July 12, 2006 |
| McDougall v. Superior Building Maintenance (No. 8) 2009 BCHRT 93 | Petition filed: May 1, 2009. B.C.S.C. Quesnel Registry No. 14081 |
| McGrath and Fox v. B.C. (Min. of Children and Family Development) 2006 BCHRT 484 | Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 180 |
| McIntosh v. Metro Aluminum Products and another 2011 BCHRT 34 | Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 345 |
| McLaughlin v. Fletcher Challenge Canada Ltd. (December 1, 1998) 1998 BCHRT 69 | Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C. Victoria Registry No. 99 0672 Appeal dismissed – 2000 BCCA 584 |
| McNeil v. Telus Employer Solutions (TES) 2022 BCHRT 46 | Petition allowed – 2023 BCSC 481 |
| Mahmoodi v. University of British Columbia (October 26, 1999) 1999 BCHRT 56 | Petition dismissed – 2001 BCSC 1256 |
| Matuszewski v. British Columbia (Ministry of Competition, Science and Enterprise) No. 2 2007 BCHRT 30 | Petition allowed – 2008 BCSC 915 |
| Mehar and others v. Interfor (No. 2) 2006 BCHRT 189 | Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 201 Appeal allowed – 2008 BCCA 204 |
| Miller v. Union of BC Performers 2020 BCHRT 133 | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1054 |
| Moore v. British Columbia (Ministry of Social Services) (November 1, 2000) | Petition dismissed – 2001 BCSC 336 |
| Moore v. British Columbia (Ministry of Education) 2005 BCHRT 580 | Petition allowed – 2008 BCSC 264 Appeal dismissed – 2010 BCCA 478 Appeal allowed – 2012 SCC 61 |
| Morgan-Hung v. Provincial Health Services and others (No. 4), 2009 BCHRT 371 | Petition dismissed June 17, 2010 (oral reasons for judgment) Appeal allowed in part – 2011 BCCA 122 |
| Morton V. BC Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General 2018 BCHRT 245 | Petition dismissed – oral ruling |
| Murphy v. Vancouver Island Health Authority and others, 2014 BCHRT 20 | Petition dismissed – December 8, 2017, 2017 BCSC 2255 |
| Mzite v. B.C. (Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General), 2012 BCHRT 53 | Petition allowed – 2013 BCSC 1116 Appeal allowed – 2014 BCCA 220 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 36041 |
N
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Naser v. Zellers and McNally (No. 2), 2006 BCHRT 427 | Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 243 |
| National Automobile, Aerospace, Transportation and General Workers of Canada (CAW-Canada) Local 111 v. Coast Mountain Bus Company (No. 9) 2008 BCHRT 52 | Petition allowed in part – 2009 BCSC 396 Appeal and cross appeal allowed in part – 2010 BCCA 447 |
| Nicolosi v. Victoria Gardens Housing Co-operative and another (No. 2), 2013 BCHRT 1 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 1989 |
| Nixon v. Vancouver Rape Relief | Petition dismissed – 2000 BCSC 889 |
| Nixon v. Vancouver Rape Relief 2002 BCHRT 1 | Petition allowed – 2003 B.C.S.C. 1936 Application for leave to intervene dismissed – 2004 BCCA 516 Appeal dismissed – 2005 BCCA 601 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31633 |
| Noël v. School District No. 23 and another, 2023 BCHRT 4 2023 BCHRT 4 | Petition dismissed – 2023 BCSC 2408 |
| Novikova v. Thompson Rivers University and another (No. 2) 2013 BCHRT 5 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 2156 |
| Ntibarimungu v. MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd. et al Letter decision dated December 7, 2005 | Petition dismissed – April 22, 2015 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Ntibarimungu v. Whistler Blackcomb / Intrawest and others 2006 BCHRT 528 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 1489 |
P
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Pardy v. Earle and others 2008 BCHRT 241 | Petition allowed in part – September 10, 2009 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Pardy v. Earle and others (No. 3) 2010 BCHRT 128 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 179 |
| Pardy v. Earle and others (No. 4) 2011 BCHRT 101 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 179 |
| Parent v. Independent School Authority and School Letter decision | Petition dismissed – 2022 BCSC 570 |
| Parent obo the Child v. The School District 2016 BCHRT 89 | Petition dismissed – February 27, 2017 – 2017 BCSC 314 Appeal allowed – 2018 BCCA 136 |
| Parent obo the Child v. The School District (No. 2) 2018 BCHRT 89 | Petition allowed – 2019 BCSC 659 |
| Parent F obo Child G v. School H and others (No. 3) 2015 BCHRT 114 | Petition dismissed – 2016 BCSC 672 |
| Patel v. Greater Vancouver Regional District, 2012 BCHRT 150 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 2154 |
| Pennock v. Centre City Drywall (No. 3), 2009 BCHRT 192 | Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 109 |
| Pirsel v. Northern Health Authority 2010 BCHRT 330 | Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 1309 |
| Pivot Legal Society v. Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association and another (No. 6) 2012 BCHRT 23 | Petition allowed – 2015 BCSC 534 Appeal allowed – 2018 BCCA 132 Costs – 2018 BCCA 228 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 38157 |
| Pivot Legal Society v. Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association and another (No. 3) 2009 BCHRT 408 | Petition allowed – 2010 BCSC 807 |
| Pivot Legal Society v. Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association and another (No. 2) 2009 BCHRT 372 | 2010 BCSC 807 |
| Poirier v. WCB and others 2006 BCHRT 236 | Petition dismissed – January 16, 2009, B.C.S.C. Vancouver, Registry No. S063973 |
Q
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Quackenbush v. Purves Ritchie Equipment Ltd. doing business as Purves Ritchie 2004 BCHRT 10 | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 246 |
| Qin v. Certified General Accountants Association of British Columbia (No. 2) 2005 BCHRT 171 | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 1662 |
R
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Reid et al. v. City of Vancouver Police Board 2000 BCHRT 30 | Petition allowed in part – 2003 BCSC 1348 Appeal allowed – 2005 BCCA 418 Application for leave to appeal dismissed – S.C.C. File No. 31171 |
| Riddle v. Town of Gibsons 2017 BCHRT 148 | Petition dismissed – June 19, 2018 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Ringham v. Domcor Health Safety and Security Inc. and another 2020 BCHRT 172 | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1023 |
| Rojas v. EaglePicher Energy Products Corp. and CAW Local 114 2005 BCHRT 17 | Petition granted in part – 2006 BCSC 1101 |
| Roos v. BC Ministry of Advanced Education and others 2018 BCHRT 197 | Petition dismissed – May 3, 2019 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Rossiter v. Lake City Casinos Limited 2005 BCHRT 46 | Petition dismissed – 2006 BCSC 88 |
| Routkovskaia v. FPI Fireplace Products International and Millichamp, 2009 BCHRT 95 | Petition dismissed – 2011 BCSC 144 Appeal dismissed – 2012 BCCA 141 |
| RR v. Vancouver Aboriginal Child and Family Services Society 2022 BCHRT 116 | Petition allowed – 2024 BCSC 97 |
| Rush v. City of Richmond and another 2011 BCHRT 244 | Petition dismissed – 2012 BCSC 1661 |
| Rush v. Fraser Health Authority 2021 BCHRT 103 | Petition allowed – 2023 BCSC 1101 |
S
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Safaei v. Vancouver Island Health Authority 2017 BCHRT 214 | Petition allowed – 2020 BCSC 1410 |
| Salvo v. Shoppers Drug Mart 2011 BCHRT 221 | Petition allowed – 2012 BCSC 1789 |
| Sanghera v. B.C. (Ministry of Attorney General and another), 2012 BCHRT 418 | Petition dismissed – September 25, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment) Appeal dismissed – 2014 BCCA 221 |
| Schell v. Blencoe | Appeal allowed – B.C.C.A.Victoria, Registry No. V03211 Appeal allowed – 2000 SCC 44 |
| Schnurr v. Douglas College and Greathouse 2007 BCHRT 40 | Petition dismissed – February 1, 2008 (Oral Reasons for Judgment) |
| Schroeder v. United Steel and another 2011 BCHRT 281 | Petition dismissed – June 6, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Sebastian v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority 2017 BCHRT 1 | Petition dismissed – May 4, 2018, 2018 BCSC 722 Appeal dismissed – 2019 BCCA 241 |
| Shannon v. British Columbia (Ministry of Government Services) 2000 BCHRT 52 | Petition dismissed – 2001 BCSC 721 |
| Sheikhzadeh-Mashgoul v. Clemas Contracting and another 2015 BCHRT 17 | Petition dismissed – 2015 BCSC 1342 Appeal allowed – 2016 BCCA 146 Appeal allowed – 2017 SCC 62 |
| Shilander v. Government of Canada and Provincial Government, British Columbia (no written decision issued) | Petition dismissed – 2005 BCSC 728 |
| Singh and another v. Workers’ Compensation Board of BC and others, 2014 BCHRT 259 | Petition dismissed – January 29, 2016 (unreported decision) |
| Singh v. Kane Shannon & Weiler, 2012 BCHRT 139 | Petition dismissed – 2014 BCSC 1043 |
| Skerry v. British Columbia (Human Rights Tribunal) 2023 BCSC 1819 | Appeal Dismissed without costs – 2024 BCCA 345 |
| Skytte v. C.N. Danroth Contracting Ltd. 2000 BCHRT 61 | Petition dismissed – 2002 BCSC 1227 |
| Sloane-Seale v. Swick’s Organic Landscaping and another (No. 2), 2012 BCHRT 22 | Petition dismissed – 2015 BCSC 2149 |
| Smith v. Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC) – Letter decision | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 331 |
| Solowan v. B.C. (Ministry of Attorney General) and others 2005 BCHRT 507 | Petition dismissed – 2007 BCSC 752 |
| Sones v. District of Squamish 2016 BCHRT 99 | Petition dismissed – February 2, 2017, 2017 BCSC 169 |
| Spina v. City of Kamloops 2019 BCHRT 107 | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 723 |
| Stein v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority and another (No. 2) 2014 BCHRT 227 | Petition dismissed – 2017 BCSC 1268 Appeal dismissed – 2018 BCCA 264 |
| Stone v. B.C. (Min. of Health Services) and others 2004 BCHRT 221 | Petition dismissed – August 3, 2005 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Suen v. Envirocon Environmental Services (No.2) 2017 BCHRT 226 | Petition dismissed – August 14, 2018, 2018 BCSC 1367 Appeal allowed – 2019 BCCA 46 Leave to appeal denied – 2019 CanLII 73206 (SCC) |
| Swetlishoff v. B.C. (Ministry of Attorney General) 2008 BCHRT 83 | Petition dismissed – 2010 BCSC 1252 |
T
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| The Employee v. British Columbia (Human Rights Tribunal) 2020 BCHRT 36 | Petition dismissed – 2020 B.C.S.C. 1706 |
| The Officer v. The Force 2019 BCHRT 171 | Petition dismissed – 2020 B.C.S.C. 1625 |
| The Parent obo The Child v. The School District, 2018 BCHRT 89 | Appeal dismissed – 2020 BCCA 333 |
| Tokash v. Nulla Bona Holdings Ltd. | Petition allowed – 2000 B.C.S.C. 502 Decision on costs – 2002 B.C.S.C. 895 |
| Torres and others v. Langtry Industries (No. 5), 2009 BCHRT 3 | Petition dismissed – 2009 BCSC 1091 |
| Tosen v. Starbucks Coffee Company and others 2023 BCHRT 83 | Application for leave to file petition dismissed – 2024 BCSC 253 |
| Tozer v. BC (Ministry of Transportation and Highway, Motor Vehicle Branch) (March 30, 1999) 1998 BCHRT 12 | Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C. Vancouver Registry No. A981344 |
| Twohey v. Bartman 2003 BCHRT 55 | Petition dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1211 |
| Twohey v. Bartman 2003 BCHRT 83 | Petition dismissed – 2004 BCSC 1211 |
V
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Verkerk v. B.C. (Ministry of Employment and Income Assistance and Ministry of Children and Family Development) 2007 BCHRT 472 | Petition allowed – 2009 BCSC 180 |
W
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Wang and others v. UBC and others 2011 BCHRT 6 | Petition dismissed – November 29, 2011 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| White v. Roxy Cabaret and Vancouver Police Board 2010 BCHRT 110 | Petition allowed – March 18, 2011 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Widenmaier v. Victoria Shipyards and others 2011 BCHRT 47 | Employer petitions allowed, union petitions allowed in part – 2012 BCSC 161 |
| Willis v. Blencoe, HMTQ as represented by the Ministry of Government Services | Petition dismissed – B.C.S.C.Victoria, Registry No. 97-4616 |
| Wilson v. Covenant House Vancouver, Letter Decision | Petition dismissed – 2021 BCSC 1876 |
| Woo v. Nisika Community Services and others, 2007 BCHRT 144 | Petition dismissed – December 19, 2007 (oral reasons for judgment) |
X
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| X.P. obo J.R. v. The Hospital and The Correctional Centre, 2018 BCHRT 4 | Petition dismissed – 2018 BCSC 2079 |
| XS v. YP, 2015 BCHRT 97 | Petition dismissed – January 20, 2016 (unpublished decision) |
Y
| Complaint name and/or Tribunal decision, date and/or citation | Result of judicial review, court registry information and/or decision |
|---|---|
| Yang v. Venegas and others (No. 2) 2007 BCHRT 50 | Petition dismissed – 2008 BCSC 1456 |
| Yaremy v. City of Vancouver and others, 2011 BCHRT 280 | Petition dismissed – 2013 BCSC 2386 Appeal dismissed – 2015 BCCA 228 |
| Yirgaw and others v. Post 83 Cooperative Housing Association 2013 BCHRT 54 (Parranto) | Petition dismissed – December 10, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Yirgaw and others v. Post 83 Cooperative Housing Association Memorandum Decision – February 21, 2013 | Petition dismissed – December 13, 2013 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Young and Young on behalf of Young v. Petres 2011 BCHRT 38 | Petition allowed – March 1, 2012 (oral reasons for judgment) |
| Yuan v. ICBC (No. 3) 2006 BCHRT 568 | Petition allowed – 2008 BCSC 1703 Appeal dismissed – 2009 BCCA 279 |